Whenever we picture a pie shop in Florida, we imagine a charming little storefront bustling with character for passersby to see and stop in for a slice. Okay, so this might sound a bit Hallmark-y to some, but hey, it’s our imagination after all! Yet, there is a hidden pie shop in Jacksonville that goes against the grain of traditional, movie-scene pie shops. Mixed Fillings in Florida is said to be the speakeasy of pies because there is no sign, and you’ll have to know in advance what door you’re actually looking for in order to get the goods.
If you want more Florida restaurants, make sure to click here and sign up for our weekly dining newsletter. Every Thursday, a new eatery to try in the Sunshine State will be delivered straight to your email. Yum!
Getting to Mixed Fillings pie shop in Florida takes a little bit of finesse, but don’t worry - it isn’t too complicated.
Google Rey C
What’s been dubbed the “speakeasy of pies” is located in Jacksonville, and requires guests to walk the side of the building, right before the mailboxes to get to the alleyway.
Google Visit Jacksonville
From there, guests meander through the secret garden, into the back of the building, where they will find…
Google Rey C
…the adorable pie window!
Facebook Mixed Fillings Pie Shop
Once you get here, it’s all smooth sailing and delicious pies. Mixed Fillings is tucked-away in Jacksonville’s historic Riverside & Avondale neighborhoods, easily becoming a go-to place for pies.
Facebook Mixed Fillings Pie Shop
The recipes are a blend of traditional pie offerings and unique flavor profiles to make for one sweet treat.
Facebook Mixed Fillings Pie Shop
Thanks to professional chef and founder Natasha Burton, Florida is able to have a taste of Texas in each and every pie.
Facebook Mixed Fillings Pie Shop
You don’t need to order up a whole pie either - although that will definitely be a crowd-pleaser at your next family gathering.
Facebook Mixed Fillings Pie Shop
You can instead order a bevy of slices so that you can try as many flavors as they have on hand that day.
Facebook Mixed Fillings Pie Shop
But keep in mind, this speakeasy of pies sells out quickly! They’re only open until 5 p.m. or if they sell out, so make sure you try to get there early.
Facebook Mixed Fillings Pie Shop
Try your hand at visiting Mixed Fillings pie shop in Jacksonville for a delightful treat tucked-away in the city.
Facebook Mixed Fillings Pie Shop
Click here to find out where Mixed Fillings is in Florida.
Google Maps
Have you ever had pie from Mixed Fillings in Florida before? Share with us your experience in the comments section! Or if you’re looking for more information about this pie shop, including current hours of operation, then check out the website or Facebook Page.
Google Rey C
Google Visit Jacksonville
Facebook Mixed Fillings Pie Shop
Google Maps
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.
Address: Mixed Fillings Pie Shop, 2251 Oak St, Jacksonville, FL 32204, USA
